Main | About | Tutorial | FAQ | Links | Wiki | Forum | World News | World Map | World Ranking | Nations | Electoral Calendar | Party Organizations | Treaties |
Login | Register |
Game Time: May 5475
Next month in: 02:03:58
Server time: 09:56:01, April 26, 2024 CET
Currently online (2): Mbites2 | Xalvas | Record: 63 on 23:13:00, July 26, 2019 CET

We are working on a brand new version of the game! If you want to stay informed, read our blog and register for our mailing list.

Bill: Security of Police Forces

Details

Submitted by[?]: Free Reform Coalition (FRP)

Status[?]: defeated

Votes: This is an ordinary bill. It requires more yes votes than no votes. This bill will not pass any sooner than the deadline.

Voting deadline: November 2042

Description[?]:

Our current gun laws allow citizens to carry lethal weapons, however our police force cannot. This bill will allow Police forces to carry lethal weaponry to ensure their security and effectiveness.

Proposals

Debate

These messages have been posted to debate on this bill:

Datenot recorded
From Free Reform Coalition (FRP)
ToDebating the Security of Police Forces
MessageIf our police forces are expected to function properly, they must be able to defend themselves against lethal attacks.

Datenot recorded
FromSocial Republican Party
ToDebating the Security of Police Forces
MessageYou make a good point, however, perhaps we should look in the other direction and reduce the gun freedoms.

Datenot recorded
FromLeviathan Party
ToDebating the Security of Police Forces
MessageAs noted when the choice to carry non-lethal weapons was made, guns are still available, they simply aren't carried as standard armament. This prevents accidental shootings and ensures that when lethal force is used it is, in fact, warranted.

There are more than effective non-lethal means available, such as air tasers, that can incapacitate a suspect without requiring the officer to get within arm's reach.

Datenot recorded
FromUnited Socialist Party
ToDebating the Security of Police Forces
MessageThe non-lethal weapons available today is as efficiant as any normal weapon that the police would have access to, with one importan factor removed, they do not kill.

The police is still, of course, obligied to protect civilians and the society with all means necessary and we would assume that such equipment that is used to bring down villains before they could hurt the society/population would be available at say, the trunks of their cars and in each police-station.

Datenot recorded
From Free Reform Coalition (FRP)
ToDebating the Security of Police Forces
MessageWhile your example of air tasers sounds lovely. It is far from realistic. Air taser effectiveness is quite low and the alternatives (pepper spray, friction lock batons (2 types) and the long (Arnold) Baton) are not as effective against someone with a gun. Furthermore, studies have shown that police officers that are equipped with tasers use them more as routine measure of force rather than as a method of incapacitating a dangerous criminal.
Here are two sites, one attesting to the ability of the taser itself, the other referring to the problems associated with tasers.
http://www.azcentral.com/specials/special43/articles/0121Taser-Police-ON.html
http://www.mindfully.org/Technology/2004/Taser-Safety-Challenged26nov04.htm

Datenot recorded
From Free Reform Coalition (FRP)
ToDebating the Security of Police Forces
MessageThe FRP would be perfectly happy with the current police enforcement laws if it were not for the fact that there are legal ways for citizens to acquire lethal weapons for themselves. A well trained police force is less likely to kill someone accidentally than a someone with a gun in their own home. American statistical information can easily show you that.

Datenot recorded
From Free Reform Coalition (FRP)
ToDebating the Security of Police Forces
MessageAlso, making gun ownership in this country legal allows a weapons industry to exist the previously would not. That makes it far more easy for criminals to acquire weapons through illegal channels. No matter how much regulation there is, there will still be this factor to consider.

Datenot recorded
From Free Reform Coalition (FRP)
ToDebating the Security of Police Forces
MessageAnother example of taser abuse:
http://abcnews.go.com/GMA/Technology/story?id=455192&page=1

Datenot recorded
FromLeviathan Party
ToDebating the Security of Police Forces
MessageGun ownership is legal in Malivia. Check the law.

Datenot recorded
From Protectorate Party
ToDebating the Security of Police Forces
MessageI believe that is the point of the FRP, since guns are legal by not allowing our police force access to them puts them at a disadvantage. The bad guys will have guns the good guys won't. Since it is often an unknown factor when first encountering a criminal if they are armed or not, the police will not be armed with deadly force. Thus they will be out gunned resulting in the possible loss of life before sufficient force can be applied. Please note this does not necessarily mean the PP is in favor of this bill just trying to understand the debate.

Datenot recorded
From Protectorate Party
ToDebating the Security of Police Forces
MessageThough it is kind of odd to allow the general population to walk around armed while the police cannot. We will investigate the effectiveness of non lethal alternatives before formulating our position.

Datenot recorded
From Free Reform Coalition (FRP)
ToDebating the Security of Police Forces
MessageI know guns are legal.

Datenot recorded
FromLeviathan Party
ToDebating the Security of Police Forces
MessageThe point being, if you think legal firearms are the problem then address the problem directly, rather than legislating on tangents.

Datenot recorded
From Free Reform Coalition (FRP)
ToDebating the Security of Police Forces
MessageThere are also other reasons for providing the police force with lethal weapons. It acts as a deterrence towards criminals in the processing of being arrested. The threat of lethal force will act as a method of controlling a situation.

Datenot recorded
From Free Reform Coalition (FRP)
ToDebating the Security of Police Forces
MessagePardon the poor grammar in the previous sentence.

Clarification: Lethal weapons will be a deterrent for criminals who are intercepted or found by police forces.

Datenot recorded
FromLeviathan Party
ToDebating the Security of Police Forces
MessageOr it will spur criminals to shoot first, knowing the only way to evade the police is to kill them. Either is equally likely.

Datenot recorded
FromRadical Centrists
ToDebating the Security of Police Forces
MessageThe status quo does appear to be problematic. perhaps we should restrict the right to bear arms?

Datenot recorded
FromLeviathan Party
ToDebating the Security of Police Forces
MessageWe already have restricted the right to bear arms. Others are free to attempt to restrict it further, but they will do so without our support.

Datenot recorded
From Free Reform Coalition (FRP)
ToDebating the Security of Police Forces
MessageI'm moving this to a vote.

Datenot recorded
From Free Reform Coalition (FRP)
ToDebating the Security of Police Forces
MessageThe FRP supports limited gun ownership by civilians, but if there is to be parity then Police Forces must be able to defend themselves appropriately.

Datenot recorded
From Free Reform Coalition (FRP)
ToDebating the Security of Police Forces
MessageFrom the sound of it, the LP does not mind that the Police Forces cannot adequately act as a deterrent against crime nor defend themselves. Since they do not support this bill and they appear to still want citizens to have lethal weapons.

subscribe to this discussion - unsubscribe

Voting

Vote Seats
yes
 

Total Seats: 11

no
       

Total Seats: 89

abstain

    Total Seats: 0


    Random fact: Don't vote yes on a cabinet coalition that doesn't give you the power that you deserve.

    Random quote: "The avoidance of taxes is the only intellectual pursuit that still carries any reward." - John Maynard Keynes

    This page was generated with PHP
    Copyright 2004-2010 Wouter Lievens
    Queries performed: 87