We are working on a brand new version of the game! If you want to stay informed, read our blog and register for our mailing list.
Bill: Immigration and Border Policy Reform Act
Details
Submitted by[?]: Rutanian Heritage Party
Status[?]: defeated
Votes: This is an ordinary bill. It requires more yes votes than no votes. This bill will not pass any sooner than the deadline.
Voting deadline: September 2760
Description[?]:
| The 'Rutanian Heritage Party' proposes a series of comprehensive reforms to immigration, refugee and border control policies that prioritize the interests Rutania and its people, first and foremost. Article 1 - Illegal aliens undermine job markets and wages; bring their poverty with them, putting an unnecessary burden on tax-payer funded welfare services; cause over-population; do not assimilate into our society, undermining social cohesion; form segregated communities and gangs; and, in many cases, commit crimes at much higher rates than Rutanian citizens. Whilst it would be a further burden on tax-payers for the federal government to fund constant efforts to search houses for illegal aliens - and whilst this is extremely invasive and inconsistent with private property rights - there is no reason that illegal aliens should not be immediately deported when found. As such, we propose that there be no active search for illegal aliens, as this process would be troublesome in many ways, but that illegal aliens should be deported upon being discovered. Article 2 - In the interests of social cohesion, it is important that all immigrants who come to Rutania are properly integrated into our society. It is, naturally, much simpler for some cultural groups to be absorbed into society than others, and this should be a consideration in forming immigration policy. If Rutania is overwhelmed by a disproportionate number of immigrants from a certain country or cultural background - particularly one that is not harmonious with our own - it will become much harder for them to assimilate properly, and they will inevitably segregate, causing cultural division, backlash and tension. For this reason, we propose that immigration quotas be based on nationality. Article 3 - Whilst it is noble to sympathize with the plight of those much less fortunate than ourselves, who have been forced to evacuate their country for reasons of war or domestic turmoil, Rutania's interests and the interests of its people should always come first. As with illegal immigrants, refugees make little effort to integrate into our society, and often bring their poverty with them, putting an enormous strain on the welfare system and increasing unemployment rates. Additionally, like illegal immigrants, refugees are often from poor nations where crime and disease is rampant, and so, naturally, they bring their crime and disease with them also. Whilst we sympathize with those who have fled their country, we do not believe we should allow thousands of people to enter our nation on the grounds of 'compassion'. Rutania must always come first. Therefore, we propose that no refugees be allowed onto Rutania's shores. Article 4 - Border control is vital for the national security of Rutania - the more lenient our border control policies are, the easier it is for terrorists, serious criminals and other undesirables to enter our nation freely, putting Rutanian citizens at great risk. The government's first obligation is to the people of Rutania, and, as such, their safety and security is paramount in all matters of border control. It is better that we impose strict controls and security background checks on visitors than giving criminals free access to Rutania. Therefore, we propose a tightening of border security policies, for the welfare of this nation. |
Proposals
Article 1
Proposal[?] to change
The government's stance on illegal aliens.
Old value:: The government does not actively search for illegal aliens, but puts them in integration centers when discovered.
Current: The government does not actively search for illegal aliens, but puts them in integration centers when discovered.
Proposed: The government does not actively search for illegal aliens, but expels them from the country when discovered.
Article 2
Proposal[?] to change Government policy concerning immigration.
Old value:: Everyone is allowed to reside permanently in this nation.
Current: Quotas are based on individual applicant's qualifications.
Proposed: No foreigners are permitted to reside permanently in this nation.
Article 3
Proposal[?] to change The national refugee policy.
Old value:: All refugees are welcome, regardless of their reason, and given aid in integrating them into the country.
Current: All refugees are welcome, regardless of their reason, and given aid in integrating them into the country.
Proposed: No refugees are allowed to enter the country.
Article 4
Proposal[?] to change Travel by foreigners to the nation.
Old value:: The nation imposes no border controls on visitors.
Current: The nation imposes minimal border controls on visitors, with cursory security checks, to confirm visitor identities.
Proposed: The nation imposes strict border control on visitors, with intensive security checks, to maintain law and order.
Debate
These messages have been posted to debate on this bill:
| Date | 20:34:26, May 20, 2009 CET | From |  Popular Socialist Liberation Movement | To | Debating the Immigration and Border Policy Reform Act |
| Message | We can't support RHP proposal. |
| Date | 15:26:32, May 22, 2009 CET | From | Rutanian Elitist Party | To | Debating the Immigration and Border Policy Reform Act |
| Message | We have a strong willingness to have a good relationship with the RHP but this bill is completely unacceptable for us, so we do not have any choice but to oppose it. |
| Date | 04:17:10, May 23, 2009 CET | From | Rutanian Heritage Party | To | Debating the Immigration and Border Policy Reform Act |
| Message | We understand the 'REP's concerns with this legislation, and we harbour no ill feelings towards the party for their opposition to it. However, we believe that the primary reason most parties oppose legislation of this kind is that they believe that it is somehow 'racist'. We assure our fellow parties that we are not a 'racist' party - we believe that race is a purely social and not a political issue, and is, in fact, fairly trivial. This legislation is not about race. This legislation is about culture and social cohesion; it is about the safety and security of Rutania and its people; and it is about jobs and wages. We do not expect our fellow parties to reconsider their position on this legislation based on what we have just mentioned, but we hope that this will at least give them a different perspective on the issue and dispel the myth that this kind of legislation is racist or racialist in any way. |
subscribe to this discussion - unsubscribe
Voting
| Vote | Seats | ||||
| yes | Total Seats: 94 | ||||
| no | Total Seats: 153 | ||||
| abstain | Total Seats: 58 |
| Random fact: Dorvik is a nation based on Germanic and old Prussian cultures, it is located on the far north of Artania, making it an almost arctic nation. |
| Random quote: "The more you observe politics, the more you've got to admit that each party is worse than the other." - Will Rogers |